Is this a rare souvenir?
Or is it an attempt to deliberately deceive?
This artefact is made from pottery and shows the prenomen of
Rameses II. It is on display in the Egypt Centre. It was purchased at auction
by Wellcome in 1934.
Such objects are often mistaken for the bases of funerary
cones, however they are an early form of copy. It would be unlikely to simply
have the base of a cone surviving.
You can see that this has a cartouche of a king’s name. One
of the things that makes it even more certain that they are fakes is that kings
did not have funerary cones. Most, unlike ours, bear the cartouche of Ramesses
III. So ours is a bit unusual.
Cyril Aldred (1957) recognised these as forgeries based on
funerary cones. He quotes an 1884 letter from Charles Edwin Wilbour which says
‘I visited the woman Giudeeyeh, who showed me the (modern) stamp from which she
moulds and bakes the round brick stamps of Rameses III, that are always offered
to you in his temple at Medinet Haboo. She lives north of Yussuf and I
encouraged her industry; it saves monuments from destruction.’
Apparently, such items also turn up today on ebay.
With thanks to Tom Hardwick for drawing our attention to ours.
Aldred, C. 1957. ‘The Funerary Cones’ of Ramesses III’. Journal
of Egyptian Archaeology 43, 113.
There is some more about these here: http://www.collector-antiquities.com/real-or-fake/fake-egyptian/fake-funerary-cones/fake-egyptian-funerary-cones-2/fake-funerary-cones-page-3.html
No comments:
Post a Comment